Departmental Policies
1. Introduction
2. Definition of Graduate Faculty
3. Guidance Committee Member Status
4. Selection of the Major Professor
5. Procedure for Changing Major
Professor
6. Admission Status
7. Assistantships
8. The Research Project
9. Policy on Authorship
Other Degree Requirements
Introduction
It is important that the student should become very familiar with this
section. Although considerable detail is presented here, it is not expected that answers
are provided to all questions. Unforeseen questions will arise and answers will be needed.
In most cases, the student's major professor, the Department Office, or Department
Chairperson will be able to provide the required information immediately. Other, more
complex issues will require the advice and action of certain Departmental Committees
and/or the graduate faculty.
Definition of Graduate Faculty
Faculty eligible for graduate teaching and guidance committee positions
constitute the Department of Food Science and Human Nutrition graduate faculty.
The determination of a faculty member's status within graduate faculty shall be made by
the Chairperson. This determination shall be made at the time of the initial appointment
of the faculty member. A faculty member's graduate faculty status shall continue
uninterrupted for the length of his/her appointment. Changes in membership or status may
be made upon request of a faculty member or the Department Chairperson in accordance with
the criteria set forth below.
Guidance Committee Member Status
- All members of a Guidance Committee will be at the rank of assistant
professor or above.
- Committee Chairperson for Master's Plan A candidates must have experience
in designing and conducting research.
- Committee Chairperson for Ph.D. candidates must have the following:
- Earned Doctorate or rank of professor.
- Experience in designing and conducting independent research or directing
graduate student research.
NOTE: In special cases, the Department Chairperson may
authorize a faculty member not holding the rank of assistant professor or above to be a
member of a student's guidance committee if that faculty member has special competencies
and experiences which contribute specifically to the program of that student.
Selection of the Major Professor
Prior to admission, students are accepted by a major professor according to
information obtained from their application for admission and the needs of the faculty
member and graduate applicant. Entering students are encouraged to discuss thesis research
with several faculty in the Department and to review all program areas of interest to them
prior to review of the application for admission. During the first semester of study, a
student may transfer to another major professor provided it is agreed upon by the student
and the new major professor. If the student does not wish to continue with the assigned
major professor, a request for change should be initiated by the student, signed by the
student and by both the temporary and the new major professor, and should be sent to the
Department Chairperson by the end of the first semester.
The major professor is ordinarily the student's academic and research advisor. In some
cases, it may be appropriate that the student's research program is directed by another
faculty member. In that case, the academic advisor will retain the designation of major
professor and will be responsible for providing guidance for graduate course work, while
the research advisor will direct the thesis research. The graduate student's major
professor shall be a FSHN regular faculty member; the research advisor will be a regular
faculty member from MSU.
Procedure for Changing Major Professor
Students may change major professors after the first semester. The student
must discuss the change with the present major professor and the proposed new major
professor before a formal request for change is forwarded to the Department Chairperson. A
request for change of major professor must be initiated by the student and must include a
statement of the change being requested as well as a brief explanation for the change. The
signatures of both the present and the proposed major professors must be on the request.
The request for change of major professor will be reviewed and decided upon by the
Department Chairperson.
The Department bears no obligation to any student who does not wish to continue working
with his/her present major professor and who is unable to obtain the services of another
faculty member to serve in this capacity.
Admission Status
Graduate students are admitted into degree programs on Regular status or
Provisional status for various reasons. When students on Provisional status complete at
least ten semester credits with an average grade of 3.0 or better and satisfy other
criteria specified on the graduate admission form, they will be considered for Regular
status upon recommendation by their major professor.
Requirements for Admission of B.S. Students into the Ph.D. Program. Students (with only a
B.S. or B.A. degree) may be admitted directly into the Ph.D. program in either Food
Science or Human Nutrition. These students must provide evidence of exceptional
performance as indicated by letters of recommendation, grade point average and GRE scores.
There must be strong justification from both the student and the advisor as to why direct
admission into the Ph.D. program is desirable. This justification must be submitted to the
Director of Graduate Studies and will be discussed with faculty during a normally
scheduled admissions committee meeting. The Director of Graduate Studies will summarize
the review and make recommendation to the Chairperson of the Department of Food Science
and Human Nutrition for final approval of admission into the Ph.D. program. Degree
requirements will be identical to the requirements for those students entering the Ph.D.
program with a M.S. degree. Students currently in the M.S. program can transfer into the
Ph.D. program according to the guidelines set forth in the graduate student handbook.
Assistantships
Assistantship support is determined on an individual basis for students on
regular admission, depending upon recommendations, availability of funds, fellowship and
scholarship support, and grade record. Assistantships are reviewed annually by the
Departmental Chairperson and may be renewed if satisfactory progress is being made and
funds are available. Recipients of assistantships are considered as university employees
and should fill out proper forms (e.g. notification of intent to engage in outside work
for pay) when holding off-campus jobs. Students shall be informed by March 31 regarding
the status of their assistantship for the ensuing academic year. Assistantships are not
generally available to M.S. students on Plan B (non-thesis) programs, including those
transferring from Plan A to Plan B.
Departmental graduate assistantship support will be limited to the equivalent of one
calendar year for M.S. students, and two calendar years for Ph.D. students. The training
grant fellowship and/or graduate school fellowship awards will generally have the same
guidelines as the assistantship. To request possible extension of graduate assistantship
support, students may petition the Department with an accompanying letter from the major
professor. Assistantships will be terminated if the GPA is below 3.0. All courses
including collateral will be used to compute the GPA. Continuation of assistantship beyond
the first year of support is based on the needs of the department, the graduate student
and the previous performance of the graduate student.
Students holding assistantships must register for course credits in accordance with the
limits below:
| Type of Assistantship |
Minimum Credits* |
Maximum Credits* |
| 1/4 Time |
6 |
16 |
| 1/2 Time |
6 |
12 |
| 3/4 Time |
3 |
8 |
*Including credits in courses numbered 899 or 999; during the summer semester,
registration for at least 4 credits is required for all graduate assistants. This
qualifies graduate assistants for the use of student health services.
The minimum registration required of a graduate assistant during the term in which the
degree is earned will be limited to the number of credits necessary to complete the
program.
Additional benefits to graduate students on assistantships include the following:
- Exemption from out-of-state tuition.
- Tuition for 6 credits is exempted.
- Eligibility to enroll in available health programs.
- Eligibility to enroll for the optional accident coverage.
- Priority in University Housing for newly admitted assistants.
- Eligibility of campus parking permits.
- Two weeks vacation plus official university holidays.
The following meets University and Departmental definition for assistantship levels:
Level 1 - Entering M.S. or Ph.D. graduate student with less than one year's experience on
a graduate assistantship and fewer than 30 credits.
Level 2 - Second year on an assistantship as an M.S. or Ph.D. graduate student or after
earning 30 credits.
Level 3 - Graduate student earning a Ph.D. degree having received at least two year's
experience as a graduate assistant (or equivalent experience at the faculty level) and
having passed the comprehensive exam.
The change to Level 3 becomes effective the term following the successful completion of
the comprehensive exam. The Record of Comprehensive Exam must be approved by the
Department Chairperson prior to the last day of finals each semester.
If for some reason the exam is taken too late or signatures cannot be obtained to meet
approval by the Department Chairperson by the last day of finals, the change to Level 3
will not take effect until a semester later (i.e. two semesters - If Record of
Comprehensive Examination is approved too late Fall Semester, the level change would not
take place until Summer Semester).
The Research Project
The research project for a thesis or a special problem is normally selected
by the student in conference with his/her major professor. It is usually a project that
contributes to a research area for which the major professor has funds available to
support the graduate student research project.
It is strongly recommended that the student conduct a preliminary literature review to
ascertain the state of the art before in-depth laboratory or field experiments are
planned.
Space for the project and use of research laboratory facilities will be arranged, when
necessary, by the major professor.
All biochemical nutrition students (M.S. plan A and Ph.D.) will undergo an annual review
of research progress. The purpose of this meeting is to assist the student in maintaining
progress and in developing their full research potential. This review provides the student
an opportunity to update all biochemical nutrition research faculty on research progress,
and to discuss their data with faculty. The review supplements ongoing interactions
between the student and the major professor, guidance committee, lab group discussions,
and other activities designed to enhance professional development; the review does not
take the place of these important activities. Graduate students can obtain additional
information from their advisers.
Each biochemical nutrition graduate student will receive notice of the review schedule and
information about the review several months prior to the scheduled review.
Policy on Authorship
- Authorship- A person claiming authorship of a scholarly
publication must have met all of the following criteria;
- Substantial participation in conception and design of the study,
development of methodologies, or in analysis and interpretation of data;
- approval of the version of the manuscript to be submitted for
publication;
- ability to explain and defend methodology and data pertinent to their
specific contributions to the study in public or scholarly settings.
- Acknowledgment - Contributions that do not justify authorship
should be acknowledged separately in the notes to the manuscript. These may include
general supervision of a research group, assistance in obtaining funding, or technical
support.
- "Honorary Authorship" - A claim of authorship by, or
assignment of authorship to, persons who may have been associated in some way with a study
but do not meet the criteria in item 1 may constitute an unethical research practice.
- Allocation of credit and order of authorship- A senior scientist
is generally defined as the person who initiates and oversees a project, supervises and
advises the junior researchers, and makes intellectual contributions to the project. In
the case of graduate student thesis or dissertation research, the senior scientist is
usually the student's major professor.
There is no general consensus on author order on scientific papers (Food
Technol., 1989). A report by the National Academy of Sciences (NAS, 1995) states "In
many fields, the earlier a name appears in the list of authors, the greater the implied
contribution, but conventions differ greatly among disciplines and among research groups.
Sometimes the scientist with the greatest name recognition is listed first, whereas in
other fields the research leader's name is always last. In some disciplines, supervisor's
names rarely appear on papers, while in others the professor's name appears on almost
every paper that comes out of the lab. Some research groups and journals avoid these
decisions by simply listing authors alphabetically" (NAS, 1995). "Junior
researchers may be listed as coauthors or even senior authors, depending on the work and
arrangements within the research team" (NAS, 1995). It is the responsibility of the
senior scientist to assure that the contributions of study participants, both colleagues
and students, are properly recognized.
Scientific research is a continuous, ever changing process of discovery, much larger than
a single paper; as such, it is often impossible to establish a list of authors and order
of authors when a project is initiated. Thus, the general publication policy of each
senior scientist/faculty member should be discussed openly with all researchers (both
colleagues and students) at the outset of a project. Before writing the manuscript, the
faculty member should discuss author order with all authors.
- Disputes Over Authorship - Disagreements over authorship, e.g. who
has a right to be an author or the order of authorship, should be resolved by the senior
scientist in collegial consultation with the other authors. When resolution cannot be
reached by this process, the senior scientist should arrange with his or her chairperson
for arbitration by a knowledgeable and disinterested third party acceptable to all the
authors. If the authors cannot agree on a mutually acceptable arbitrator, then the Vice
President for Research and Graduate Studies shall appoint an arbitrator. During the
arbitration process all the authors are expected to refrain from unilateral actions that
may damage the authorship interests and rights of the other authors.
- Accountability - Every author listed on a publication is presumed
to have approved the final version of the manuscript. Each author is responsible for the
integrity of the research being reported. Each author should denote approval of the final
manuscript in writing using the departmental form: FSHN Authorship Designation. This
requirement is waived if a manuscript is submitted to a journal requiring sign-off by all
authors as part of the submission process.
- Plagiarism - Plagiarism is the use of ideas or words of another
person without giving appropriate credit (NAS, 1995). The expropriation of another
authors's text and the presentation of it as one's own, constitutes plagiarism.
Plagiarism, in turn, constitutes misconduct in scholarship under University policies and
procedures. Plagiarism in scholarly projects should be reported to one's chairperson,
dean, or the University Intellectual Integrity Officer.
Other Degree Requirements
Teaching Responsibilities. Students admitted prior to Fall Semester 1992 are required to
comply with the following guidelines: A M.S. graduate student is required to assist in
teaching at least two courses, and a Ph.D. graduate student is expected to assist in
teaching at least three courses during their respective graduate programs. Students
admitted Fall Semester 1992 and after are required to comply with the following
guidelines: A Ph.D. graduate student is required to assist in teaching one course during
their graduate program.
Performance. If a student's performance and/or progress does not meet departmental
requirements, he/she shall be notified by the Department Chairperson or his/her
representative. Where the deficiencies endanger the student's status in a degree program,
he/she shall be promptly informed. A graduate student will be dismissed if his/her
cumulative GPA falls below 3.0 for three consecutive semesters.
Semester Reports. The Graduate Student Semester Report form will become a permanent record
of accomplishment and will be maintained in the graduate student's departmental file. The
Graduate Student Semester Report must be submitted to the Departmental Office each
semester irrespective of the type of appointment. The report for the semester is due on
the first day of class of the next semester. Include grade report and a brief (1/2 page)
summary of research accomplishments. Important: Submit your completed form to your major
professor for his/her comments and signature. The form will be forwarded to the Director
of Graduate Studies for his/her final approval. A copy will be returned to you and your
major professor. An assistantship appointment cannot be processed unless the Semester
Report has been received by the Departmental office.
Independent Study. Students must complete an Application for Independent Study form in
order to register for FSC 890 or HNF 890. |
 |