Revised version of the
obituary published in Linguist List
19.633 (Feb. 25, 2008).
Marvin Lionel Bender, a
prominent figure in Afroasiatic and Ethiopian linguistics for 50 years and
whose works are among the authoritative sources on Omotic and Nilo-Saharan
linguistics, died on Tuesday, February 19, 2008 in Cape Girardeau, Missouri.
Born August 18, 1934 in
Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania, he received BachelorÕs and MasterÕs degrees from
Dartmouth College in mathematics, in 1956 and 1958, and Ph.D. in linguistics
from the University of Texas at Austin, in 1968. His Ph.D. dissertation was a
generative study of Amharic verb morphology.
Bender left PhD. studies at
Yale to teach mathematics at Adisadel College in Cape Coast, Ghana. During a
seminar on school mathematics at Entebbe, Uganda, he traveled to Ethiopia, and
liked it enough to apply for and accept a position at Haile Sellassie I
University, where he became interested in Amharic and linguistics, and so
returned to graduate school, at Austin, where his dissertation was directed by
Emmon Bach. After Ph.D. studies Bender was immediately recruited to the
research team of the Language Survey of Ethiopia, a Ford Foundation project
(part of the five-nation Survey of Language Use and Language Teaching in East Africa),
the other members of which were J. Donald Bowen, Robert L. Cooper, and Charles
A. Ferguson. Bender was the only one with experience in Ethiopia and knowledge
of Amharic, the Ethiopian lingua franca. The survey report, Language in Ethiopia, was published in 1976 (Oxford University Press),
including several chapters by Bender, some co-authored with Ethiopian
linguists. Words he wrote in the preface suggest the understanding about
research conclusions which was to characterize his many books and articles in
Ethiopian linguistics: Ôan attempt to summarize the state of the art...and not
a new source of orthodoxyÕ.
Over the years in the often
contentious field of Ethiopian linguistics, in which different national and
scholarly traditions compete, his freely expressed conclusions from research
–especially concerning Omotic and Nilo-Saharan classification, in which
his work became foundational– were frequently controversial, and just as
often to be superceded by findings of his later work. He was among the first to
take up the hypothesis of Harold Fleming about the status of Omotic as a
separate branch of Afroasiatic, and that of Robert Hetzron about the internal
classification of Ethiopian Semitic. Importantly, he succeeded in having both
hypotheses accepted by the survey team and written into Language in Ethiopia.
When the survey was finished,
Bender was appointed at Stanford University, to finish the Ethiopia Survey
report, where he valued his continuing relationship with Ferguson and, newly,
with Joseph Greenberg. In 1971 he joined the Department of Anthropology at
Southern Illinois University, where he remained until retirement and for a time
served as Department Chair.
His early research was to
explore, with Ethiopia as an example, FergusonÕs idea of Ôlanguage areasÕ, and
GreenbergÕs method of mass comparison as a basis for genetic language
classification and a way to bring empirical process to bear in a little
documented and diverse linguistic setting such as Ethiopia, with some 75
languages in four families. As GreenbergÕs classification of African languages
had brought order and rationality to the broad field of African linguistics,
BenderÕs would similarly serve Omotic and Nilo-Saharan. His early work also
applied lexicostatistical methods to Ethiopian languages, work which his
mathematics background prepared him for, but which sometimes enraged
conservatives, who failed to distinguish lexicostatistics and glottochronology,
or failed to see that his often original conclusions about Ethiopian-language relationships
were more a test of the method, and working hypotheses, rather than attempts to
establish Ôa new source of orthodoxyÕ.
He was the first to
systematically sort through the many problems of Ethiopian-language
nomenclature, which had arisen from decades of research in four European
languages and competing use of ethnic-group names, self-names, and Amharic
names, and failure to distinguish dialect and language, and he was the first to
attempt a catalog of all the languages and named dialects of Ethiopia,
including a first attempt at a comprehensive genetic classification: The Languages of
Ethiopia
(Anthropological
linguistics
13.5, 1971).
Turning to Omotic, Bender
took to the field and began to fulfill the need for descriptions of many of
these divergent Afroasiatic varieties. His thorough knowledge of prior work,
ability to question informants in Amharic, and the new data he acquired enabled
him to provide the first internal classification of this group, in his Omotic: a New
Afroasiatic Language Family (1975), and eventually his Comparative Morphology of the
Omotic Languages
(2000), and Omotic Lexicon and Phonology (2003). He obtained grants, including from the National Science Foundation and
Ford Foundation to study Omotic, and later Nilo-Saharan.
Soon he took up Nilo-Saharan,
an extraordinarily diverse family, with often poorly accessible members. In
order to provide the Ethiopian academic community, in and around Haile
Sellassie I University (now Addis Ababa University), with an affordable introduction
to these largely ignored and often despised peoples and their languages, he
self-published, in Addis Ababa, The Ethiopian Nilo-Saharans (1975). He was a Fulbright awardee at Khartoum University in
1978-9 and
authored, with speakers of the languages, the only dictionaries on two of these
languages: Gaam (1980) and Kunama (1996). He edited six volumes of Nilo-Saharan
papers, and initiated the Nilo-Saharan (later -Sahelian) Newsletter. BenderÕs latest book on this family was The Nilo-Saharan
Languages: a Comparative Essay (1996); he edited with Franz Rottland the Buske
series, over 23 volumes, Nilo-Saharan Linguistics Analyses and Documentation. He valued his time in the Sudan, but loved Ethiopia,
where he returned many times. His Omotic and Nilo-Saharan works are a major
contribution to the preservation of endangered languages.
Co-edited with G‡bor Tak‡cs
and David Appleyard, BenderÕs Afrasian: Selected Comparative-Historical
Afrasian Linguistic Studies in Memory of Igor M. Diakonoff (2003), to which he contributed the ÔAfrasian
overviewÕ and another article Ôthe Omotic lexiconÕ, is probably now the best
introductory source on Afroasiatic linguistics.
After retiring from Southern
Illinois University, he found new time for his long interest in chess, and
continued to write and publish with energy, despite failing health, recently
completing a book on Cushitic phonological and lexical reconstruction, about
which he was expected to present in March at the North American Conference on
Afroasiatic Linguistics (NACAL), a meeting which he rarely missed and twice
organized.
According to the obituary
written for the Carbondale community, his ashes will be scattered in Baja
California, Mexico, where he and his sons often vacationed in recent years, and
perhaps an area which brought back for him memories of fieldwork in the west
Ethiopian countryside. Memorials may be made to the Council for Secular
Humanism, in Amherst, NY (www.secularhumanism.org/).